3307 S College Ave. #107 Fort Collins, Colorado

(970) 402-2466

From 11:00 am to 7:00 pm (Sun-Tue) - From 11:00 am to 11:00 pm (Wed-Sat)

How do I sell Magic: The Gathering cards to The Haunted Game Cafe?

Looking to sell Magic: the Gathering cards to The Haunted Game Cafe? Here’s what you need to know! The Haunted Game Cafe defines cards in two ways: Singles (cards priced individually based on their specific value determined by condition, set, title, etc.) or Bulk (everything else).

  • We accept both singles and bulk on weekdays between noon and 5pm and on nights we stay open late from 8pm to 10pm. We must grade and identify every card, this usually takes around 20 to 30 minutes. 
  • If you have a large collection of singles, please make an appointment by selecting a time at this link: https://www.hauntedgamecafe.com/products/appointment-to-sell-magic-the-gathering-cards. Then, bring your cards with you to the store at that time. 
    • We only buy cards in English or Magic Language cards like Phyrexian
    • Payment Options: We pay in either cash or gift card. Gift Card Offer is 10% more than the Cash Offer. Cash payments over $150 will be through Paypal instead of cash. 
    • We buy bulk cards by type: basic land (sorted by color), full-art basic land, tokens, commons, uncommons, and rares/mythics. If you have questions regarding how to differentiate these cards, please contact us and we'll help you.
    • Cards must be unsleeved, Near Mint or Light Play, and in English.
    • We will pay the following prices for bulk cards in cash (no gift card increase):
      • 500 Commons: $1
      • 100 Uncommons: $1
      • 100 Basic Land: $0.20
      • 100 Tokens: $0.20
      • Full Art Land: $0.05 per card
      • Rare or Mythic card: $0.05 per card 

 

      The Legal Stuff:

      The Seller agrees to sell goods to The Haunted Game Cafe for an agreed upon amount of cash or a Haunted Game Cafe gift card. The Seller gives all rights of resale and receipts of resale to The Haunted Game Cafe. Seller acknowledges that the transaction is final and irreversible. There will be no further payments, no returns, and no refunds. Seller certifies that they have legal ownership of the goods, all rights to sell the goods, and that the goods were not obtained by illegal means. Seller acknowledges that the value of the goods may fluctuate post-sale. 

      book an appointment button

      BACK TO TOP